2005 Charlie Hay
2006 Charlie Hay
2007
Charlie Hay
2008 James Macadie
2009 Mrs M McDonald
2010 Gordon Muir
2011 No Entries

2012 Gordon Muir
2013 Alasdair Webster
2014 Alasdair Webster
2015 Sandy Matthew
2016 James Middleton
2017 James Middleton

MITHER TAP CHALLENGE SALVER
awarded for
The best open crank engine (Class 12b)
Bought by the Club

Winners